Tim Kaine, Virginia’s Minnesota-born, Kansas-raised junior U.S. senator, rarely passes on an opportunity to share his adoptive state’s story with others. That’s because the Democrat believes that there are lessons for the nation — good and bad — that spring from the state where it was born. In a speech at the Virginia Museum of History and Culture and in an op-ed in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, both pegged to the fast-approaching 250th anniversary of American independence, Kaine focused on Virginia’s
motto , one as old as the republic
: Sic Semper Tyrannis — Latin for “Thus always to tyrants” or “Ever thus to tyrants.” Kaine implied that its spirit should guide public and political resistance to President Donald Trump. Kaine, of course, has a front-row seat to the mayhem that supposedly qualifies as governance. And the increasingly edgy, occasionally profane manner with which Kaine characterizes Trump, his utterances and behavior suggest that the usually circumspect senator is unburdened by political considerations — that he is free to fully speak his mind because this third term in Washington is likely his last.
People are also reading…
But here’s arguing that Virginia’s other motto has greater application to our troubled times than
Sic Semper Tyrannis , a rhetorical flourish attributed to Brutus as he and others plotted the assassination of Julius Caesar in 44 B.C. and reportedly howled by John Wilkes Booth as he shot dead President Abraham Lincoln in 1865. In 1779, as the war for freedom from Great Britain raged on, the Virginia legislature adopted as the state’s secondary motto
Perseverando — Latin, for “by persevering.” More than 200 years on — as Trump perfects his I-am-the-law
schtick by ignoring Congress and defying the courts — one would admit that
Perseverando nicely complements
Sic Semper Tyrannis . After all, toppling tyrants demands perseverance. Virginians know that tyranny can take many forms — and that it is often defined by the times and those literally or figuratively shackled. It was the tax-imposing British monarchy in the late-1700s that embodied tyranny. To white Confederates, it was the North that opposed Black slavery in the South in the mid-1800s. For the once-enslaved and their descendants, it was the white oligarchy that denied Black Virginians voting and civil rights for nearly a century, beginning in the late 1800s. For LGBTQ people in the 2000s, it is the conservative politicians who used their control of government to deny them rights guaranteed for straight folks. Indeed,
Perseverando — it appears on the reverse of the seal, paired with likenesses of three classical goddesses representing liberty, eternity and agriculture — works much better than the original secondary motto, also in Latin, that it replaced,
Deus Nobis Haec Otia Fecit — “God has given us these days of leisure.” By the way, it’s the motto of
Liverpool , England, a major slaving port in the 18th century and where the Beatles got their start in the 20th. That motto’s sentiment seems far removed from the noble, grinding, sometimes-bloody enterprise that is the struggle for — and to preserve — freedom. The jettisoned motto — it was done away with three years after it was adopted — could conjure an image of Hawaiian shirt-wearing sybarites stretched out on beach chairs along the edge of a noisy, smoke-shrouded battlefield, sipping tropical drinks and taking in the combat as if it were a surfing competition. Not even Thomas Jefferson liked it. In a July 30, 1776, letter to John Page, a future congressman and Virginia governor from Gloucester County whom Jefferson would defeat in his first try for that office, the Muck-a-Muck of Monticello — busy at the time in Philadelphia helping birth the new republic — reported that most people in and around the Pennsylvania State House, now known as Independence Hall, considered the motto a head-scratcher. Jefferson was delighted, though, with
Sic Semper Tyrannis . It, along with the secondary motto, was the handiwork of a committee of heavyweights: George Mason, George Wythe, Richard Henry Lee and Robert Carter Nicholas. The foursome also designed Virginia’s seal, the primary feature of which is the
bare-breasted Virtus — avert your eyes Ken Cuccinelli! — a drawn sword in her right hand, a spear in her left and her foot atop the toppled tyrant, whose crown has fallen from his head. The whole package was adopted by the Virginia Convention of 1776. “I like the device of the first side of the seal much,” wrote Jefferson, a detail-oriented aesthete from Albemarle County. “The second I think is you much crouded, nor is the design so striking. But for god’s sake what is the ‘deus nobia haec otia fact. It puzzles every body here. This device is to aenigmatical, since if it puzzles now, it will absolutely insoluble fifty years hence!” Thanks to the Library of Virginia — especially to Becky Schneider, the interim archives and reference services manager and the state’s chief librarian, Dennis Clark — the story behind those little words that appear on the state seal is a lot bigger. And while the seals and the accompanying mottoes might seem arty affectations of eras long passed, they remain to this day emblems of the authority extended to officialdom by those who installed them: the people. In 1777, with the seal, itself, being prepared by a Philadelphia engraver “at publick charge,” according to 18th-century records, a Virginia representative to France — he was seeking arms and cash for the colonial cause — had “no seal to authenticate his credentials, and the delay in obtaining the seal ordered in Philadelphia was the source of considerable annoyance,” wrote state librarian H.R. McIlwaine in a 1909-10 report on possible modifications to the seal. By law, there are two seals — the great and the lesser. They are distinguished by size, with the former, 2 3/4 inches in diameter, about twice as large as the latter. The great seal is reserved for validating documents signed by the governor and used in legal proceedings or Virginia’s dealings with other states. The lesser seal is affixed to grants for land, writs ordering elections, gubernatorial pardons and reprieves as well as commissions and appointments — civil and military. The keeper of the seal is the secretary of the commonwealth, a political appointee of the governor who dispenses patronage jobs and — perhaps prized even more than a seat on a high-profile board or commission — those two- and three-digit license plates that are supposed to telegraph to fellow motorists that the driver who may have whizzed by, well over the speed limit, has an influential friend in Richmond. At a time when politics and policy are shaped by bitter wars of will rather than thoughtful, interested debate, the relevance of Virginia’s mottoes endure. That said,
Sic Semper Tyrannis is prospective in tone, aspirational.
Perseverando speaks to the struggle and the vigilance that should continue even after a tyrant is toppled; to discourage and thwart those who might rise in his or her stead. In the years immediately following the Civil War, when Virginia was restored to the union, largely under the supervision of federal troops, its Reconstruction governor was viewed as taking a somewhat tyrannical approach to altering the seal. Francis
Pierpont wanted to add the words, “Liberty and Union.” Though the changes were sanctioned by the legislature in 1866, there were doubts whether it was done legally. Within a decade, the additional words were removed. But because, in a Virginia given to Shintoism, the old is venerated, there was a push in the early 1900s to drop
Perseverando, replacing it with the original secondary motto. A report to the Library Board, observing that the seal was “lacking ... in artistic grace and beauty,” suggested that its historical symmetry could be restored by reviving
Deus Nobis Haec Otio Fecit , then translated as, “God has given us this ease.” The effort was turned back — if only because of
Perseverando . And speaking of: For those of us in print journalism, particularly in these times, it seems one often gets through the day by persevering. I did — happily — at The Times-Dispatch, for 39 years, four months and 29 days. This is my final column for the newspaper. I’ll be keeping an eye on Virginia politics as a part-time analyst for Radio IQ, the Roanoke-based, statewide public broadcasting outfit. You can reach me via . Thank you for putting up with me — and for keeping me in touch.
Perseverando .
From the Archives: The Virginia state Capitol building
01-29-1970 (cutline): Capitol is focus for women lobbyists' work during session. 01-23-1973 (cutline): Maybe a last look--legislative page David King, 13, looks at model of the State Capitol by Thomas Jefferson which soon may be removed from the building. 02-06-1962 (cutline): Byrd (left) and Del. Pollard view model of Capitol at Commitees' session yesterday. 10-10-1963: Capitol's lunch room. 03-13-1972: Inside of Capitol. 01-13-1962 (cutline): Virginia's Capitol early today, all ready for the Harrison inaguration ceremony. 02-21-1968 (cutline): Sign proclaims 'Fire Lane' along north side of Capitol. Parked cars are almost bumper-to-bumper, but Fire Chief is tolerant. 03-12-1974:In March 1974 at the state Capitol, Virginia first lady Katherine Godwin (second front right) unveiled a painting of the Virginia Declaration of Rights. The work, by Jack Clifton of Hampton (front), was presented by the Virginia Daughters of the American Revolution; it commissioned the painting in cooperation with the Virginia Independence Bicentennial Commission. Assisting Godwin with the unveiling were state Sen. Edward E. Willey Sr. of Richmond and DAR official Mrs. John S. Biscoe.