*Originally published in October 2020
Updated on October 15, 2024:

From creamy pumpkin to indulgent chocolate—what's your ultimate Thanksgiving pie pick?

Ah, Thanksgiving ... when else will you gorge yourself on eight different kinds of carbs before going on a really slow walk? You have to cap off the meal with something sweet, but cake is a bit too much. Ice cream is too plain on its own, and candy is kids' stuff.

There's something magical about a really good pie. Flaky crust and a decadent filling are paired with a little something creamy. What's not to love? Here's how we'd rank some of the most popular Thanksgiving pies. Have you tried all of these?

No. 7: Chess Pie

This sweet Southern classic is a creamy, cool end to a long meal. Sometimes spiked with lemon juice, chess pie is a unique dessert that will delight the crowd.

No. 6: Pecan Pie

Coming in a close second, pecan pie is a sweet, nutty slice of heaven. With a filling that's both gooey and crunchy, it offers an indulgent contrast of textures that keeps everyone coming back for seconds. Plus, it brings that satisfying caramel flavor without being overly rich.

No. 5: Sweet Potato Pie

Like pumpkin pie’s cousin, sweet potato pie offers its own unique charm. With a slightly lighter and sweeter filling, it's perfect for those who want a slightly different yet equally delicious dessert. It’s a comforting staple in many households during holiday gatherings.

No. 4: Cranberry Pie

Cranberry pie might not be on everyone's radar, but it definitely deserves a spot on your Thanksgiving table. Its sweet and tart flavor profile offers something special, breaking up other pies' rich, buttery goodness. It's a refreshing twist that brightens up the dessert spread.

No. 3: Apple Pie

Who could resist a slice of warm apple pie? Known for its comforting blend of tart apples, cinnamon, and flaky crust, this pie is perfect with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Its balance of sweet and tart is a crowd-pleaser and keeps it firmly on the holiday menu.

No. 2: Chocolate Cream Pie

It’s like a slice of pure joy with a smooth, dreamy filling and whipped cream topping. The crumbly crust adds just the right touch of texture, making it a standout option on any holiday dessert table. Who can say no to chocolate? Not us!

No. 1: Pumpkin Pie

Ah, the classic pumpkin pie—nothing screams Thanksgiving quite like it! With its creamy texture, perfect blend of spices, and buttery crust, it's no wonder this pie takes the top spot. It's practically synonymous with holiday tradition and nostalgia.

So, there you have it: a delightful ranking that will hopefully spark some pie-in-the-sky debates over the Thanksgiving table!